Observation of people and events is common to all creatives. Cartooning is not so different from writing. You can spoil a very good joke with a bum punchline, one that is too wordy, or fails to have enough, one that merely underlines the scene rather than adding to it. The crimes are many and rarely are they spotted with such care unless one is under the eye of a fellow cartoonist, or even worse, the cartoon editor.
Everyone else merely says it is funny or not funny, which is how it should be.
Anyway, drawing cartoons is the least of it. The writing really does matter, and I can spend a long time just looking a picture that I have drawn, wondering what it was meant to say.
I mentioned last week that the New Yorker had published a quiz of cartoons for muggles to assess. Thanks for all the emails letting me know you got five out of five, by the way. Yes, it appears that I am a muggle in my own profession. However they've gone one better and thrown open a contest in which you must create your own cartoon.
Don't worry if you can't draw. The New Yorker has sorted that for you. You can choose different elements from a pre selected set up, though you'll have to register. In my opinion this is actually a lot harder than just having a pen, paper and some intoxicants to hand, but have a go here.
Here's mine, after ten minutes of deep thought:









